*
Stones
Porter Norton McDonald
*
L*STS: an Essay Daily Happening | About & Contents
Lists | Lasts | Losts | Lusts | Lests | Other
*
The word for pebble in Hebrew is tz’zor. It is also the word for bond. In Jewish tradition it is customary to leave a pebble or stone atop a grave to show that you were there, that you remembered. This custom ties back to sitting shiva, the seven day mourning period associated with Jewish funerals. Like a stone, the mourner sits, while friends and family visit and help with the prayers, with the grief.
Cemeteries, like church, never held much importance to me as a child. I don’t remember ever visiting a family grave. I never laid flowers, never whispered in quiet conversation with the dead. Our dead were cremated. Their ashes were sown into the sea or sprinkled beneath apple trees. No stones. Death in my family was fine and fleeting, meant to be released, meant to be taken by winds and scattered, and, given time, meant to be forgotten. But I like stones. Stones are good at sitting.
No one ever spoke of our Jewish heritage. Like a handful of ash, this side of the family was scattered by the gusty winds of Wall Street or maybe swept under a carpet of some Upper West Side apartment. We only found out about the Wertheimer’s after my older sister stumbled upon their graves while doing some internet sleuthing. We were all surprised, but my Mom most of all. How had no one told us that we were Jewish? Who was it that decided to intentionally erase this vibrant part of our family story? Like a game of Clue, the mystery became a wild period of pointing fingers. “It was your Grandma Anne in her sailboat with a bottle of gin!” “No, it was your great-grandmother Dorothy on 5th Avenue with a D.A.R. membership card!” One thing we all agreed upon was that this was some WASP-y bullshit
I needed to place stones on my ancestor’s graves. I needed the weight of my stones to pin Dorothy Sprague to her lie. J’accuse! I needed our lost dead to know that they were found. They were purposefully forgotten, but here is my stone. You are known. You will be remembered. I wanted my stones to hold them down in time like a paperweight so they wouldn’t blow away again. I wanted my stones to pile up like cairns, like markers to guide distant cousins to me. I’m here! I’m right here! Do you see me?
*
I don’t have an obsession with death, per se, just my own death. To be more specific, I have an obsession with my funeral. Funerals are ceremonies wasted on the living. My fixation on planning my end of times started well before my fixation on being Jewish, but both topics elicit heavy eyerolls from my friends and family.
“Load my body into the back of your car and drive out to the desert,” I say. “When nobody’s looking, pop the trunk and hit the gas. Bob’s your uncle.”
I had just outlined my current postmortem scheme to Mike and Lisa, my good friends and hosts in Teaneck, New Jersey, where I’d be staying for the New York City leg of my ancestry research trip. We were well into our first (or maybe third) cocktail. Okay, by we I mean me, but I was drinking rye whiskey, and since my third-great grandfather was a distiller, this was “research.
“Look, all I’m saying is keep it simple.”
As I expected, the room went quiet. And then came the comments.
“Yeah, Porter…I’m pretty sure that’s illegal.”
“That’s not a funeral. That’s a body dump.”
“Yeah, I’m not doing that.”
There are so many ways to handle the dead body of a loved one. You can embalm and entomb it, preserving the flesh and pomp for eternity (or close to it). You can stick it in a sack with some soil and the root ball of a sapling. As previously mentioned, you can burn it up until only dust remains. Perhaps more should be said here about the reality of cremains, because it isn’t a can of ethereal fluff. Cremains are lumpy. And there are bone bits (nobody ever mentions the bone bits). Cremains will kill a sapling in less than a year. When our dog Roscoe died, my wife and I buried his ashes under a beautiful (and expensive) Ruby Red Grapefruit tree. Within three months, the leaves dropped and the once-vibrant branches dried and browned. So we dug up the tree, now cursing the ghost of our dog. Then we shot the hole with a deluge of hose water in an attempt to wash Roscoe out of the hole. We mixed in “Happy Frog” compost. We planted a new tree into the now-steaming mud wound, a Blood Orange. The new tree died within two months.
Don’t plant a tree over your cremains.
But fear not. Today there are many companies that have developed crafty ways of dealing with your beloved’s ashes. Here are a few:
- You can melt and mix them into stained glass.
- You can mix them in clay and make a little pot.
- You can mix them into a glaze for said little pot.
- You can melt, mix and press them into a vinyl record.
- You can melt, mix and squirt them through a 3-D printer.
- You can even melt, mix and compress them into a diamond and wear Gramma around your neck.
As I scrolled through the copious crematory options, I was amazed at the connection between human ashes and ballistics:
- You can shoot them out of a cannon (if you’re Hunter S. Thompson).
- You can shoot them into space (if you’re rich enough).
- You can shoot them off in a fireworks display (if you’re not rich enough).
- You can compress them into bullets and then shoot them off (if vengeance is your thing).
I want none of that.
Roll me into the desert and let the scavengers have their fill. Farm to table.
*
My obsession with death began at an early age, probably at the moment of birth. My mom’s father Richard died of nephritis in 1950. He was only twenty-six. My mom grew up never knowing her father, and had to scavenge for the few stories of his flash-in-the-pan life. Just like our Jewish heritage, her family let go of his life, letting it blow away in the wind off Long Island Sound. The few stories she had were repeated like litany, how he would mime eating a juicy peach, how he drove over a land mine in France and thought he was blind (it was mud on his glasses), how his arms looked just like mine with only a whisper of blonde hair. My mother longed for stories of her father and this longing was passed down to me. What comes of a life when its stories are no longer told?
My mother had an older brother, also Richard, but we all called him Dick. When I was nine, Uncle Dick suddenly died of a staff infection. He was only forty-one years old. He went to the dentist on Thursday with a high fever and was dead by Saturday. I remember my mom coming into my room when she found out he was in the hospital dying. I remember her waking me up crying and holding me and telling me that she needed to leave for a few days. I remember this was the first time I had really seen my mother weep, seen her knocked off her foundation, and I remember it frightened me a little.
We all drove up to Maine for his memorial service. I remember adults milling around speaking in hushed tones. I remember muted colors and a blanket of gray clouds, but maybe that’s just me projecting “somber”. I remember wondering if the men in my family were cursed to die young. I remember wondering what age I would die and how I would be remembered. Most of all I remember two objects.
The first object was Uncle Dick’s old Stetson cowboy hat, which I asked for and received. This hat would follow me through many adventures, but that’s the subject of another essay. The second object was a mix tape. Two actually. These two tapes, like the hat, would play a fundamental role in who I became and how I thought about death.
Dick was an audiophile. His record collection was a treasure, and when he died, my mom and his best friend went through his vinyl, pulling choice tracks and recording them onto two cassette tapes.
These songs and that hat would fuel a trajectory of folk music, guitar picking, and blues crooning that—much to my teenage daughters’ dismay—I am still on today. “But let me tell you why this song was so important….”
I used to think that Dick’s music was him reaching back through time to shepherd me through my early teenhood, but really it was my Mom. Maybe she was making sure he wasn’t forgotten by inserting a little banjo and Delta blues into my formative years.
*
My wife is usually the one on the receiving end of my funereal preoccupation.
“Steal my body.”
“What?!”
“Steal my body…from the funeral home. Like Gram Parsons. His friends stole his body and burned it on a funeral pyre in Joshua Tree. Or Ed Abbey, his friends boosted his corpse and buried it out in the desert.”
“I’m not stealing your body!”
“It’s a thing.”
“I’m not going to jail for your funeral.”
“This really limits my options.”
In addition to bearing the responsibility of actualizing my funeral ideas—one scheme involved an exploding casket that would shower raw meat upon the mourners (that was a hard no)—my poor wife has also been plagued with trying to remember all the songs I want played at my funeral. Eventually she forced me to just write them down. I was recently surprised that, considering my unhealthy obsession with my own death, the Funeral Songs playlist in my Spotify account only has eight songs on it. And these eight songs aren’t all winners. Perhaps I forgot about the list when I came up with the body dump idea? Currently, my Funeral Songs playlist consists of the following tracks. I tried to arrange them in order starting with a few sad and pensive numbers to play as folks are seated, wiping eyes behind black veils, etc. Cue the sad music.
- “Dress Sexy at my Funeral” —Smog
- “Hard Drive” —Evan Dando
- “My Blue Heaven” —Gene Austin
And then come the pallbearers. Oh yeah, we’re in a church. Yeah, I know. I’m not religious, but so what? Six handsome men in black suits come dancing out with my coffin to tune of:
- “Goin’ Down Slow”- Bobby Blue Bland
This song is my piece de resistance. There is a version of this song on Dick’s medley by Geoff Mulduar titled “I Have Had my Fun,” which is essentially the same song, but there’s an incredible cathartic build in Bland’s version. Even though I’m pretty sure it’s about a guy dying of an STD, I still think it fits.
Back to my funeral. The pallbearers have reached the altar (is that the correct direction for the body to travel?). We’re right at the end of the song, and there are horns and backup vocals and electric lead guitar, and we’re building to a climax here, when suddenly my coffin blows open! And like Dracula rising from the dead, out pops a life-like mannequin of my body. BOOM! Jump scare! I look fabulous, of course. I’m dressed in a suit covered in silver sequins. Cue the next track:
- “96 Tears” —? and the Mysterions
“Too many teardrops for one heartache…” Aretha Franklin’s version is on Tape 2 Side B, but I prefer the bouncy organ and wild 1960s garage band zeal of ? and the Mysterions. In the church, now the sounds of laughter overpower the weeping. Too many teardrops, baby. It’s time to boogie! The church turns into a dance party like that scene in Blues Brothers. Maybe my coffin is full of ice cold beer?
- “Fantastic Man” —William Onyeabor
Because only a fantastic man would plan a party like this, right?
- “Pressure Drop” —Toots & the Maytalls
Sweet relief.
- “Sweet Talkin’ Lady” —Electric Light Orchestra
Yeah, I’m not sure how this got onto my funeral playlist, but it’s a damn good song, and I can’t seem to remove it. Don’t be hatin’ on ELO.
When I get into my funeral planning mode it can last awhile. I usually lose my friends and family in the process. My eyes get glassy. I get out of breath. My wife has to wait until I eventually lose steam and then, with a polite but pointed, “Remember, funerals are for the living,” she brings me back. And damn, she’s right. But what I wouldn’t give to attend my own funeral.
*
I never wanted a gravestone. I never wanted to take up any additional space on this earth. I still don’t, to some degree. But then I started visiting cemeteries. Troy Hill was first on my research trip. It was also my first journey among the steep slopes of Pittsburgh. Up, up, up. One-and-a-half lane streets, hairpin turns. I love the ever-present geography here, the ridges and rivers always asking something of their inhabitants, both uniting and dividing a population, allowing for each neighborhood to evolve its own endemic history, ethnicity and personality. Sara Petyk, my Pittsburgh host, told me she used to lead bike tours up to Troy Hill. My thighs balk just thinking about the trek. Apparently, Troy Hill used to be a German neighborhood and just about every family there would grow their own hops, brew their own beer, and store their homebrew in the many caves that dimple the hillside. But I wasn’t there to search for centuries-old pilsner. I was there to visit the grave of Bella Wertheimer, and to do that, I had to drive up to the top of Troy Hill to the first Jewish burial ground in Pittsburgh.
Two days prior, I spent a morning in the basement archive room of Rodef Shalom reading through the 1875-1906 meeting notes of the Bes Almon Association, the oldest Jewish organization in Pittsburgh, of which my family were active members. It was mostly yellowed pages, slanted ink, but also some insight into the work it takes to keep community and tradition alive in a rapidly changing United States. Much of the first few pages of the notebook were filled with notes on how to obtain land for a burial ground, which was important because there are many rules about how to deal with the dead. First and foremost, according to Halacha or Jewish law, the Jewish community must own the cemetery, and the deceased must own the plot, deed in dead hand. While that might be an exaggeration, it does create a memorable image. The members of Bes Almon had to purchase land, keep accurate records of who purchased which plot, and maintain the long and somewhat treacherous road up, up, up to the top of Troy Hill.
Second rule of a Jewish cemetery is that those buried in it must be Jewish. This seems obvious, I suppose, but it does get a little tricky when Jews start marrying gentiles and gentiles convert to Judaism. Could I be buried in a Jewish cemetery? According to Jewish law, I think so? “Ah,” say those that have noticed the tattoos adorning my skin. “You are far too inked to be buried with your Hebraic ancestors.” This is a myth. Traditionally, true. Nowadays, not so much. The idea goes back to keuod ha-met or “treating the dead and dead bodies with respect.” Cremations are still forbidden in Jewish burial practices and, I imagine, so too is rolling a corpse out the back of a car. Autopsies and organ donations, while traditionally forbidden, are now generally tolerated. Amputees are okay, too, especially if you can bury the severed limb in a clearly delineated and properly deeded plot with a promise of reunion once you shuck your mortal coil.
The cemetery up on Troy Hill was small. About the amount of land you’d need for a couple of small houses with enough yard for a swing set and charcoal grill. My unit of measurement came easy since small houses and yards with swing sets and charcoal grills were what surrounded the graveyard, enveloped it. I parked as close to the remarkably unmarked gate as I could without blocking people into their driveway. Or maybe I was in a driveway? The single-story home directly abutting the cemetery was missing its aluminum siding, exposing Tyvek like a fresh scrape. The site was on the side of a hill, not quite on the top, so I hefted my cameras and notebooks up to the top and began to methodically wind my way down, looking for Bella Wertheimer.
A jay was screaming itself hoarse from somewhere inside a bent pine. It was cloudy and gray. Perfect graveyard weather. The headstones seemed ancient. Some had tipped forward and now lay face down in the earth, collapsed as if exhausted from the weight of marking a life. I walked slowly, respectfully, reading names like a mantra, feeling the syllables roll out my mouth, wondering if anyone kept their stories. Some headstones—the inexpensive ones, I imagine—were blank, the names washed away by almost two hundred years of rain and snow and the acidic excretions of moss and lichen. What happens when your name is no longer legible? Is that the last step? Are you officially forgotten? And why does that terrify me?
Bella’s grave was obvious in the end, and stood out with somewhat ostentatious pride. It was immense compared to every grave around it (how did I not notice it at once?). It was shaped like a bed, or maybe a lounge chair you might find by a pool, but made of stone. It reminded me of the kind of grave in a Hammer film upon which you’d find a sexy vampiress sprawling seductively. It was the only one of its kind. Clearly the Werthheimers had money. Was that the message? I had forgotten a pebble, so I pinched a piece of gravel from the driveway near my car. Was this a fancy enough stone for Bella Wertheimer? It was rough, grayish green, and slightly pyramidal. I rubbed at a smudge of asphalt on the corner before gently placing it on her headstone and returning to my car for the long drive down Troy Hill.
*
The essay, “Stones”, is the result of two phenomena from my past. The first, an obsession with my own death—specifically my funeral—derived from the early deaths of many of the men in my family. The second was the intentional erasure of my Jewish heritage, not by state-sponsored genocide, but an equally insidious form of antisemitism: capitalism. The above tragedies left lacunas in the lives of my family, holes that I have attempted to fill in with research, holes that I now mark with the stones of my artwork.
Porter Norton McDonald is an interdisciplinary artist exploring narrative and the interplay between image and text. His work includes illustration, sequential art, book art, poetry and performance. By exposing the methods and structures used to create narrative, the mechanisms lurking in the shadows off stage, Porter draws attention to the craft of storytelling, the role of the narrator and the blurry the line between truth and fiction. Porter’s art has been shown internationally at the Czong Institute for Contemporary Art in Kimpo-si, Korea and the Museo de Arte de Sonora in Hermosillo, Mexico. His work has also appeared in Tucson, Arizona at the Steinfeld Gallery, Pidgin Palace Arts, the Lionel Rombach Gallery and the Mexican Consulate. He has performed excerpts from his current book On Dogs on TV at Wave Archive, Desierto Books (Tucson) and the Poetry Lounge (Pittsburgh). Porter is an MFA graduate in Illustration/Design/Animation at the University of Arizona (2027).



